Kayo's Thoughts

Writer – Chaos Business Lady

Felicis
Kayo

I write anything I thought.
I share what I knew.

kayo-avatar

Development of the English and Welsh Judiciary

Cues (Key Ideas / Questions)Notes (Detailed Summary)
Origins & EvolutionThe system evolved over 1,000+ years; known for independence and fairness. Initially governed by lords (local) and the King (royal).
Trial by OrdealUsed until 1216. Painful methods to determine guilt (e.g., hot iron, boiling water). Church condemned the practice. William II banned it.
Trial by CombatUsed for criminal & civil cases. Declined over time; banned in 1818.
First Judges12th-century royal advisers; became ‘justices in Eyre’ with judicial/admin powers. Unpopular instruments of royal authority.
Henry II ReformsIntroduced juries (12 knights); only 18 judges in his reign. Assize of Clarendon (1166) created judicial circuits → basis for common law.
King’s Bench Origins1178: 5 chosen to hear complaints → Court of Common Pleas. Led to creation of King’s Bench and later Court of Exchequer (financial).
Professional JudiciaryEarly judges were clergy; later included knights and serjeants-at-law (legal professionals). Eventually, barristers and solicitors.
Judicial Corruption & SalariesBribery common. 1346 oath against corruption. Salaries increased. Thorpe (Chief Justice) sentenced for bribery (later pardoned).
Magistrates’ CourtsOrigin in 1285 under Edward I: “good and lawful men” kept peace. Handle ~95% of criminal cases today.
Judges & Politics14th-century judges still involved politically. Richard II case (1387) led to executions/exile → judiciary withdrew from politics.
Tudor Period OnwardJudges stayed out of Privy Council from 1540. Reformation increased state’s control over law. Judges interpreted, not made law.
17th Century Judicial RiskCharles I agreed to “good behaviour” appointments. But Charles II & James II removed many judges → instability and lack of independence.
Act of Settlement 1701Guaranteed judicial security: salaries from public funds; removal only “by law” → foundation of judicial independence.
Court of ChanceryAlternative to common law; focused on equity. Became slow, costly, and unpredictable. Rivalled common law until 19th century.
19th Century Reforms1830: Welsh courts integrated. 1846: County Courts Act. 1856: judges allowed to try cases outside jurisdiction.
Judicature Act 1873Merged common law and equity. Created High Court & Court of Appeal. Criminal appeals: Court of Criminal Appeal (1907–1966).
Creation of Crown Court1956 in 2 cities. 1971 Courts Act unified assize & quarter sessions into single Crown Court system.
Final Separation (2005–06)Constitutional Reform Act 2005 removed Lord Chancellor from judiciary. Lord Chief Justice became Head. Ministers must uphold independence.